Star of the Seas vs Icon of the Seas: What's Really New on Royal Caribbean's Newest Cruise Ship?
Royal Caribbean is back at it again with Star of the Seas, the second ship in their groundbreaking Icon Class. With the Icon of the Seas making waves as the ultimate family cruise ship, many cruisers are wondering:
“Is Star of the Seas really different — or just a copy of Icon of the Seas with a new name?”
After spending time onboard both ships, we discovered plenty of hidden differences that make Star of the Seas stand out — and some surprising similarities that Royal Caribbean fans will love.
Whether you're planning your first Icon Class cruise or deciding between Star vs Icon, here’s everything you need to know before you book.
Royal Caribbean’s Star of the Seas Newest Largest Cruise Ship in the World. Comparing Star and Icon
1. The Pearl – Same Iconic Sculpture, But With a Twist
At first glance, The Pearl, Royal Caribbean’s massive kinetic art installation, looks identical to Icon’s version.
But look closer and you’ll notice:
Upgraded kinetic panels with smoother movement
Vibrant, multicolor backlighting that gives it extra pop at night
Still holds the title of largest kinetic sculpture at sea
It’s a subtle change, but it sets the tone for Star’s updated art experience.
2. New Chief Dog Officer 🐾
Every Icon Class ship has an adorable Chief Dog Officer.
Icon of the Seas introduced us to Rover
Star of the Seas debuts Sailor — ready to melt your heart and pose for selfies.
This might seem like a small change, but it’s a fun detail that Royal Caribbean fans will appreciate.
3. Pearl Café & Grab-and-Go Dining
The beloved Pearl Café is back with:
24/7 grab-and-go snacks
Breakfast, lunch, and dinner options
Coffee, pastries, and late-night bites
The layout and menu are almost identical to Icon’s, but the surrounding artwork and sea-life theme have been given a refresh.
4. New Dining Experiences – Lincoln Park Supper Club
While Icon of the Seas featured the Empire Supper Club, Star has swapped it out for:
Lincoln Park Supper Club – an upscale dining experience with a Chicago flair
Elegant atmosphere perfect for a romantic date night or special celebration
If you loved Empire, you’ll want to give Lincoln Park a try.
5. Surfside Neighborhood – Expanded for Families
On Icon, Surfside was designed for kids ages 0-6.
Star takes it a step further:
Now accommodates kids up to age 10
Same family favorites like Surfside Eatery, Lemon Post, and the ice cream shop
Subtle design changes, like a flamingo wearing a lei instead of a tie (because details matter!)
This makes Star slightly more versatile for families with older kids.
6. Complimentary Dining at Base Camp
Big news for foodies: Base Camp, located near Thrill Island, was a specialty dining venue on Icon.
On Star, it’s now included with your cruise fare!
Pro tip: Grab some tater tots from Base Camp and load them up with toppings from El Loco Fresh for the ultimate cruise snack hack.
7. Thrill Island & Water Slides
Both ships feature Category 6, the record-breaking water park at sea with six massive slides, including:
Frightening Bolt – the tallest drop slide at sea
Family raft rides
Racing mat slides
These remain the same, so adrenaline junkies will be equally happy on either ship.
8. Crown’s Edge Returns
The heart-pounding Crown’s Edge experience is back!
This one-of-a-kind attraction combines:
A ropes course
A zipline
A moment where you dangle over the ocean before swinging back onto the ship
It’s an absolute must-try for thrill-seekers.
9. Aquadome Market – More Food Options
The Aquadome Market was already a favorite on Icon, and now Star takes it further with even more variety:
Feta Mediterranean (fan favorite)
Crepes
New additions: Thai, Pig Out BBQ, and empanadas
This makes it one of the most diverse and exciting dining areas on any Royal Caribbean ship.
10. Entertainment Upgrades
Star of the Seas introduces exclusive shows, including:
Torque – a jaw-dropping Aqua Theater show with high dives from 82 feet up
Soul – a brand-new ice skating performance at Absolute Zero
Back to the Future Musical – exclusive to Star, bringing Broadway energy to the high seas
11. Top Deck Additions – More Pools & Hot Tubs
Star features:
Seven pools, including the only swim-up bar at sea (Swim & Tonic)
Ten hot tubs — one more than Icon
The Hideaway – an adults-only infinity pool retreat with breathtaking views
12. Small But Notable Changes
Pub name changed to Thorn & Thistle
New planet-head sculptures are scattered throughout the ship
Slightly redesigned signage and art for a unique vibe
Final Thoughts – Star vs Icon
So, is Star of the Seas just a clone of Icon?
Not exactly.
While the core design and major attractions are the same, Star offers:
More complimentary dining
Expanded family spaces
Refreshed entertainment and art
A few exclusive shows and surprises
If you’ve sailed on Icon before, Star will feel familiar — but with just enough differences to make it worth booking.